Lucas & Spielberg's Death Knell and What it Means for Indie Creators

By Anjum Bhardwaj, posted 1 July 2013

At a recent talk at the USC School of Cinematic Arts, George Lucas and Stephen Spielberg made some interesting predictions about the future of the film industry. In a nutshell, they both agreed that some major changes are coming to the box office, culminating in an implosion that will forever change the face of filmmaking.

The crux of their argument is rooted in something that no filmmaker should see as a surprise: Hollywood is risk-averse, and the channels for entry are growing ever narrower. In other words, small, thoughtful, avant garde or experimental movies are hard to make and even harder to distribute, while multi-million-dollar action films tend to be a safer bet - unless, of course, they flop.

Heavy Words From Industry Giants

The surprising thing about this talk wasn't its message, but the speaker. Lucas and Spielberg aren't exactly known for their thoughtful, introspective movies. Lincoln gave Spielberg a glimpse of the struggle that other filmmakers have experienced for years - he mentions in his USC talk that the movie was almost sold through HBO rather than released on the big screen.

George Lucas, too, lamented the high cost of making movies and the way that all films need to be mass-marketed rather than targeted to niche audiences - again, hardly a surprise for most of us, but who can fault a pair of blockbuster tycoons for being late to the party?

That's not to say their passion for indie (or avant garde) film isn't genuine, of course - both have freely given guest lectures on the topic to students at a film school in NYC - but while their concern for the future of the industry feels a little disingenuous, it might not be wholly inaccurate.

A Question of Sustainability

As studios demand ever-bigger spectacles, quieter movies will fall by the wayside or find alternate paths to viewers. Eventually, this path will be unsustainable as several big-ticket, high-budget films begin to bomb. After driving away all of the competition, the theory goes, a handful of huge movies will dominate the market - and it's possible that no one will then bother to go see them.



Or, as Lucas predicts, maybe the box office will start to work more like live theatre, with headlining acts charging higher ticket prices and lasting for longer runs while chancier films are cheaper and last just a few weeks. Even then, though, the model might not be sustainable. The cost of creating a mega blockbuster is simply too high to hope to recover on every release, and focusing too much attention on these huge films could lead to the entire industry imploding on itself.

The question is, what would the movie industry look like after such a cataclysmic event? And, more importantly, would such an implosion be such a bad thing?

First, it's not entirely fair to suggest that only big-ticket movies ever get produced and distributed to major theaters. Of course, the pickings seem a bit bleak throughout the summer months when glossy high-budget action movies are the trend du jour, but there's always room for commercially successful, critically acclaimed thoughtful films. Lincoln, for its part, grossed a commendable $275 million, and this year's The Great Gatsby currently sits in the top 10 highest-grossing films for 2013. So while the experimental film might be suffering, reports of its death are highly exaggerated.

Not All Doom and Gloom

But even assuming that quiet films can't find a home in theaters, the fact is that there are more distribution channels available than ever before. People haven't stopped wanting to watch great stories; they've just changed the way they consume them. The Internet, the great equalizer, has made it easy to sell movies directly to the audience that will most appreciate them. Filmmakers can distribute their movies through Netflix, Crackle, IndieFlix, and many other platforms. Crowdfunding has also become a very viable option for securing distribution funds, and even YouTube has shown worth as a film hosting platform.



And, of course, there's premium television. Cable programming is free of many of the restrictions placed on films, and it allows its creators to develop more avant garde long-form stories than could ever be possible on the big screen. With so many audience members choosing to stay home and consume this media at their leisure, is it any wonder that they're foregoing the pricier, crowded movie theater experience?

Spielberg and Lucas are right about one thing: The current Hollywood model is unsustainable. But that's something to celebrate, not mourn. Whenever one giant falls, it can be replaced by a nimbler, more dynamic system. Ultimately, the death of the current system would be a boon to any aspiring filmmaker looking to find an audience.

Reader Comments

K.Hungus, 31-Jul-2013
So, they're saying what independent filmmakers have been saying for 20 years... Wow, so brave.

More Posts

4 Filmmaking 'Rabbit Holes' To Avoid

Brian O'Malley from Screenplay Readers takes a look at four areas in the filmmaking process which can end up derailing an otherwise great project.

7-Mar-2018  • 

RED Announces the New Monstro 8K VV Full-Frame Sensor for WEAPON Cameras

RED has had an 8K sensor available for sometime in the form of the RED Dragon VV, but the announcement of the Monstro represents a significant step forward in both quality and simplification of the workflow.

10-Oct-2017  •  Benjamin Craig

Blocker App Brings Augmented Reality Shot-Planning to Your iPhone

With iOS 11 hot of the production line, mixed reality agency AfterNow has wasted no time leveraging Apple's ARKit to deliver a free augmented reality tool to help directors compose their scenes.

27-Sep-2017  •  Benjamin Craig

12 Angry Men- A Lesson in Staging

Using Sidney Lumet's '12 Angry Men', Andrew Saladino from The Royal Ocean Film Society looks at how blocking and staging can add emotion and density to scenes which may otherwise end up rather dull.

11-Sep-2017  •  Benjamin Craig

How to Make a Blockbuster Movie Trailer

The super-talented Craven Moorhaus and Zak Koonce (aka Auralnauts) have created the perfect blueprint for your blockbuster movie trailer.

18-Aug-2017  •  Benjamin Craig